Minister still entitled to refuse future Ward Union licence
07 May 2008
Environment Minister John Gormley has clarified that the settlement he reached with the Ward Union last month does not prevent him from refusing a licence to the controversial hunt next season. The Minister was responding to a Dail question from ICABS vice-president, Tony Gregory, TD.
The full text of the question and answer follows:
Question 193 - Answered on 1st May, 2008
Tony Gregory: To ask the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government the full details of his out of court settlement with a group (details supplied); the conditions by which a licence may be granted for carted deer hunting; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Written reply. Ref No: 17026/08
Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government (Mr. Gormley): This settlement with the Ward Union Hunt Club provides that I, as Minister, am entitled, under the Wildlife Act 1976 (as amended), to grant or refuse any application to hunt, while confirming that certain conditions included in the licence issued in December 2007 will not be re-imposed.
I will supply a copy of the settlement to the Deputy and I am happy to brief him further if requested.
For more animal-related Dail Questions and Answers, please visit our Politicians Page
Minister Gormley settles with Ward Union
The Irish Council Against Blood Sports has learned that Environment Minister, John Gormley, has settled out of court with the controversial Ward Union carted deer hunt. The settlement relates to conditions imposed by the Minister as part of a restricted hunting licence he issued last December.
In a statement from the Minister's office, ICABS has been told that "the terms of the settlement are that the case will be dropped, and that the Minister will not impose conditions 12 and 13 on this or future licences, should such licences be granted. There is also an agreement that decisions on future licence applications will be taken within a reasonable timeframe."
The restricted licence issued by the Green Party Minister to the hunt disallowed the use of dogs to chase the deer and prompted the hunt to seek a Judicial Review on the matter. They subsequently won an injunction, preventing the Minister from enforcing certain conditions.
For over 150 years now, the Ward Union hunt has been subjecting tame deer to a distressing ordeal, leaving them exhausted, often injured and at risk of dying from heart failure. Under the Freedom of Information Act, incidents of cruelty have been documented, such as deer dying of aneurisms; a deer choked on capture; a deer drowned in a quarry; a deer sustaining fractured ribs and dying; a deer hanging by its front leg on barbed wire; a deer clearly exhausted with its tongue hanging out and lameness in deer following hunts. These incidents are just the tip of the iceberg, we believe.
The Irish Council Against Blood Sports has always contended that this hunt should never have been licensed and this has now been borne out by Professors William Binchy and Clive Symmons of Trinity School of Law in a recently published legal opinion which concludes that the Ward Union hunt is "illegal" under the 1911 Protection of Animals Act, and that it shouldn't be licensed under the 1976 Wildlife Act. Our campaign to bring the Ward Union hunt to an end continues.
Restate your opposition to cruel carted deer hunting and ask Minister Gormley to deny any further licence to the Ward Union (as is his right as Environment Minister).
Minister John Gormley
Dear Minister Gormley,
I am writing to urge you, as a Green Party Minister, to do everything in your power to prevent the Ward Union from resuming their terrorisation of deer. According to legal experts, this hunt is illegal. Please refuse further licences to this cruel hunt which a majority of people in County Meath and many more around Ireland and the world want stopped.
Thank you. I look forward to your response.
Videos: Carted deer hunting cruelty
Photos: carted deer hunting cruelty
Photos: carted deer hunting cruelty